JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.

You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website. Click here for instructions on enabling javascript in your browser.

You have 1 item(s) in your shopping cart, click here to proceed to our secure checkout.

During warmer weather months shipping chocolates can be a bit tricky. Please read and accept our warm weather shipping conditions in order to proceed. Warm weather shipping terms and conditions

Latest Updates

Due to the current shelter-in-place order we are offering FREE shipping on ALL orders over $25!

Please read this important update regarding our shop and COVID-19: Click here to read our message
Betsy\'s Peanut Butter Cream
Price: $14.50

Available Options:

Box Size:
Chocolate Type:
Delivery date:

If there is a specific date you need your order delivered by please enter it here.

Please note that delivery dates are approximates based on past delivery and production times. We will do everything in our power to get your order delivered on time for you!

Rich, creamy organic peanut butter with just the right amount of sweetness and finely ground peanuts.  Our Betsys Peanut Butter Cream is perfect for the peanut butter + chocolate lovers out there.  If you really like peanut butter, this is for you!  Your choice of creamy milk chocolate or rich dark chocolate.

Average user rating 5/5
based on 5 ratings.


Simply put, Sweetness and Light is a chocolate lover's paradise. No other confectionery comes close. My wife and I have ...

Rated by MD

These are delicious; they melt in your mouth. The creamy filling is to die for! The bonus for me is ...

Rated by ALICE K.

These are the absolute best dairy free bon bons I have tasted! ...

Rated by ALICE K.

I love these bonbons, they are so rich and creamy. The dark chocolate ones are dairy free! ...

Rated by Alice Kable

Have you tried our Betsy's Peanut Butter Cream? Write a review